West Wing Wiki
West Wing Wiki

Toby – By the way: you are a beautiful woman. And no one around here has ever assumed you were either ambitious or stupid
C.J. – Toby? Took two years

EMMY WINNER JOHN LARROQUETTE GUEST-STARS AS FORCEFUL WHITE HOUSE COUNSEL WHO DISLIKES NEW HIRE -- President Bartlet's (Martin Sheen) controversial -- and conservative -- new choice for associate White House counsel (guest star Emily Procter) has rough sledding on her first day when she suffers the wrath of her hostile boss (Emmy-winning guest star John Larroquette, "Night Court," "The Practice"), gets a chilly reception from her co-workers and is humiliated by two other staffers (guest stars Steven Flynn and Paul Perri). Also, when Josh's (Bradley Whitford) insurance company turns down his claim for his recent life-saving medical bills, Sam (Rob Lowe) tries to convince him to sue the people who shot him. In addition, C.J. (Emmy winner Allison Janney) tries to shame an outspoken general (guest star Tom Bower), who is critical of the President, into meeting with her.



Josh is back in the West Wing, and is upset that his insurance company is trying to collect $50,000 USD for his medical expenses, but Sam tells him not to worry about it. Donna is in charge of escorting some visitors to the White House into the Oval Office to hear the President record his weekly radio address, but is concerned that the President might not take it seriously, citing a previous incident where the guests were sent home after 11 attempts. Things don't get off to a great start, as the President stops to laugh at the term "leaf peeping".

Act I[]

C.J. has gotten over the hiring of Ainsley Hayes, but is concerned that sexism is holding her back. Toby warns her that a retiring Army Chief of Staff is going on the press shows, and they suspect that he's going to criticize the President.

Leo introduces Ainsley to her boss, the firebrand White House Counsel Lionel Tribbey (played by John Larroquette), who is already in a bad mood because White House staffers Steve Joyce and Mark Brookline lied to Congress about a memo, interrupting his vacation plans. Upset, Tribbey storms into the Oval Office, interrupting the recording of the weekly radio address, which had been going well until that point. The President convinces Tribbey not to have this discussion in front of the people there to hear him record the address.

Sam is trying to help Josh get out of trouble with the insurance company, but an off-hand comment from Toby makes him consider that they should attempt to sue the hate groups that are connected to the shooting.

Act II[]

Donna and Josh discuss the fact that the President has not actually finished the recording yet, but are interrupted by Sam calling to ask Josh to come discuss the suing the KKK, using subpoenas and depositions to uncover the membership rolls and their ties to related groups.

Mrs. Bartlet asks Charlie to pass the President a note that they can begin having sex again, and the President is eager - but they have to plan around their schedules, before the First Lady has to fly out. The Army Chief of Staff has sent an aide to C.J.'s office. The aide conveys the General's disagreements with the President's policies, but CJ sends the aide back with a message: "tell General Barrie C.J. Cregg says he's a coward."

Leo is helping Ainsley find her office deep in the basement of the White House, and he tells her the others will come around, citing some of the attacks the staff have endured from various members of the Republican party, including Ainsley herself. "Don't worry about [the others]," he tells her. "You're here to serve the President. Anyway, welcome to the White House."

Act III[]

Lionel Tribbey storms into Ainsley's basement office, demanding she tell him why she's here in the White House, and she tells him that she feels "a sense of duty." This leads to a debate about Gilbert and Sullivan, whose operettas are "all about duty": Tribbey insists that the song "He Is An Englishman" comes from their operetta "The Pirates of Penzance," while Ainsley correctly says that it's from "H.M.S. Pinafore."

Tribbey assigns Ainsley to deal with Congress regarding the staffers who lied under oath, and she tells him that she knows he's also there out of a sense of duty.

Josh and Sam continue to discuss the lawsuit against the KKK, while Leo asks Sam to talk to Joyce and Brookline about their testimony on the Rockland memo, explaining that Ainsley has been sent to discuss it with Congress. Sam expresses concerns that they've sent her, but Toby tells Sam to back down, even though he later admits to Leo about having some of the same concerns. Josh asks Toby and Leo how they feel about the idea of suing the KKK, and they are both concerned about the counter-suits that could come up, forcing White House staffers to answer embarrassing questions, but they will back Josh if he decides to go ahead with the suit.

Donna brings a new audience into the Oval Office as they try again to record the radio address. The President realizes that it's time for his appointment with his wife, but Charlie tells him that the First Lady had to leave for Pennsylvania early.

General Barrie storms into C.J.'s office, and they argue about his concerns about the President's defense policies. C.J. notes that the General is wearing a medal that he was never actually awarded, and implies that if he goes forward with his plan to denounce the President, she will reveal this to the media, and the General leaves.

Act IV[]

Ainsley returns from the Hill and approaches Joyce and Brookline, telling them they can resolve all this by apologizing. They are incredibly rude and dismissive, an extension of the attitude that they used when testifying, and ignore Ainsley's suggestion.

The President meets the First Lady in the residence, but while making small talk he is casually dismissive of Abbey's mission to dedicate a statue to Nellie Bly. Abbey is offended and begins to lecture the President about how the historical impact of women has been largely overlooked. The President realizes, to his chagrin, that his plans for a romantic moment have been totally derailed.

Josh tries to tell Sam that he doesn't want to sue the KKK, but he is interrupted as Sam storms out to dress Ainsley down for speaking to Brookline and Joyce. Ainsley asks Sam if he can save it for tomorrow, telling him that she cannot bear another disappointment on her first day at the White House. Sam follows her to her office to apologize, where they see an arrangement of dead flowers with a card inscribed "Bitch". Sam realizes that Brookline and Joyce sent it, and he storms out to confront them. He fires them both, and Tribbey is there to back him up. Afterwards, Tribbey and Sam continue the debate about Gilbert and Sullivan, with Sam taking Ainsley's side.

Saturday morning has come, and the President is doing a live radio broadcast on some of the women who have had an important influence on the history of the United States, with the First Lady looking on. As they both head up to the residence, the President stops to instruct C.J. to let General Barrie express his opinion on the talk shows, saying his service to the country has earned him that right.

Josh tells Sam that a lawsuit doesn't feel like the right way to handle what happened to him, and they go down to wait with C.J. and Toby in Ainsley's office to greet her with an impromptu rendition of the song "He Is An Englishman."


Rob Lowe as Sam Seaborn
Dulé Hill as Charlie Young
Allison Janney as C.J. Cregg
Janel Moloney as Donna Moss
Richard Schiff as Toby Ziegler
John Spencer as Leo McGarry
Bradley Whitford as Josh Lyman
and Martin Sheen as President Bartlet

Special Guest Stars

Stockard Channing as Abigail Bartlet
John Larroquette as Lionel Tribbey

Guest Starring

Emily Procter as Ainsley Hayes
Daniel Roebuck as Lieutenant Buckley
Tom Bower as General Ed Barrie
Paul Perri as Steve Joyce
Steven Flynn as Mark Brookline
Kathryn Joosten as Dolores Landingham
NiCole Robinson as Margaret Hooper


Melissa Fitzgerald as Carol Fitzpatrick
Kim Webster as Ginger
Karen Lockhart as OEOB Staffer
Jack Shearer as Engineer
Bradley James as Donnie


Well, obviously, Lionel Tribbey is a brilliant lawyer whom we cannot live without, or there would be very little reason not to put him in prison
—President Bartlet
Ainsley – Lionel Tribbey thinks hiring me was a great idea?
Leo – Why are you surprised?
Ainsley – Well, because I am a Republican and Lionel Tribbey is... incredibly not
— Wait for it
Ainsley – So you lied to me just then
Leo – I'm a politician, Ainsley. Of course I lied to you just then
Ainsley – My first day is getting off to a great start
— Post-Tribbey
Ainsley – I'd like to do well on this, my first assignment. Any advice you could give me that might point me the way of success would be, by me, appreciated
Tribbey – [pause] Well, not speaking in iambic pentameter might be a step in the right direction
Ainsley – The President's way too moderate for your taste
Tribbey – Excuse me?
Ainsley – On affirmative action, capital gains, public schools, free trade... You left a lucrative practice in Chicago and a seven-figure income... It wasn't out of a sense of duty?
Sam Seaborn: Do you have any idea how big a harassment suit you just exposed us to? She just... She works here. Which is more than I can say for either one of you.
[He takes a pen and scribbles on Joyce's desk blotter as they watch. He holds it up: "You're fired - S. Seaborn"]
Sam Seaborn: You're fired. S. Seaborn.
Mark Brookline: Sam, I don't know who you think you are around here, but you can't fire us.
Lionel Tribbey, White House Counsel: Oh... yes. He can. Leave here, and don't ever come back. It's time for both of you to write your book now.
President Josiah Bartlet: You know what I did, just then, that was stupid? I minimized the importance of the statue that was dedicated to Nellie Bly, an extraordinary woman to whom we all owe a great deal.
Abbey Bartlet: You don't know who she is, do you?
President Josiah Bartlet: [to himself] This isn't happening to me.
Abbey Bartlet: She pioneered investigative journalism.
President Josiah Bartlet: Then she's the one I want to beat the crap out of.
Abbey Bartlet: She risked her life by having herself committed to a mental institution for ten days so she could write about it. She changed entirely the way we treat the mentally ill in this country.
President Josiah Bartlet: Yes. Abigail...
Abbey Bartlet: In 1890, she traveled around the world in 72 days, 6 hours, 11 minutes and 14 seconds, besting by more than one week, Jules Verne's 80 days.
President Josiah Bartlet: She sounds like an incredible woman Abbey. I'm particularly impressed that she beat a fictional record. If she goes down 21 000 leagues under the sea, I'll name a damn school after her! Let's have sex.
Abbey Bartlet: When it comes to historical figures being memorialized in this country, women have been largely overlooked. Nellie Bly is just the tip of the iceberg.
President Josiah Bartlet: I couldn't possibly hear about the rest of the iceberg right now.
Abbey Bartlet: Elizabeth Blackwell was the first American woman to be awarded an MD. She founded the Women's Medical College...
President Josiah Bartlet: Keep talking. I'm just gonna sit here and think about plutonium and the things I can do with it.[1]


  • The words "Donna's Birthday" appear on Josh's blackboard, implying her birthday was around the time the episode was set.


  • The title of this episode is taken from song "For He is an Englishman" (which is sung by the cast in the final scene of the episode) from Gilbert and Sullivan's operetta H.M.S. Pinafore. The actual line reads:
"He is an Englishman/for he himself has said it/and it's greatly to his credit/That he is an Englishman"
  • Despite everybody's insistence that all of Gilbert and Sullivan's plays are about duty, the operetta H.M.S. Pinafore, which is frequently referred to in this episode, is mainly about differences in social class.
  • Lionel Tribbey is correct in his statement that The Pirates of Penzance is about duty. The full title of The Pirates of Penzance is actually The Pirates of Penzance, or The Slave of Duty.


  • General Barrie is identified as the outgoing Army Chief of Staff and is depicted as a three-star general. However, all chiefs of staff for the Army and Air Force; the Chief of Naval Operations; and the Commandants of both the Coast Guard and Marine Corps all hold flag ranks (general or admiral) of four-stars. Historically, this was not always true, but it has been for the better part of the last century. Goofs involving military protocol, units, and hardware are common on The West Wing.[1]


Notes and references[]

  1. 1.0 1.1 "The West Wing" And It's Surely to Their Credit (2000) — Quotes and trivia copied from IMDb